(KAIR)--The proposed demolition of a historic former Atchison elementary school to make way for Benedictine College's planned School of Osteopathic Medicine campus will be considered Monday afternoon by the Atchison City Commission.
Commissioners are scheduled to review a resolution concerning the former John A. Martin Grade School, commonly known as Martin East, at 507 Unity Street. The building, which has been vacant since 1997, is listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
Benedictine College, which owns the property, has proposed demolishing the building and replacing it with a new facility as part of its planned medical school campus.
According to documents included in the agenda packet for Monday's meeting, the college examined the possibility of rehabilitating the existing structure but determined that its deteriorating condition, safety concerns, renovation costs and limitations of the building's layout made that option impractical.
The proposed demolition has also prompted a historic preservation review.
The Kansas State Historic Preservation Office determined that demolition would harm the historic structure, triggering a requirement under state law for the city to consider whether a feasible and prudent alternative exists.
Commissioners will consider Resolution 3461, which would formally determine that no such alternative exists and that the project includes planning to minimize harm to the historic property.
City records indicate that the former school has changed ownership several times since closing in 1997, with various redevelopment proposals failing to move forward.
Those efforts included proposals to convert the building into affordable housing, market-rate apartments and student housing.
A report prepared by city economic development consultant Justin Pregont outlines the history of those unsuccessful proposals, including attempts to obtain historic preservation tax credits and other financial assistance.
More recently, Benedictine College explored incorporating the existing building into its proposed medical school facilities. However, the college's review found that the structure could not reasonably accommodate the space, accessibility and technical requirements of the planned campus.
In his November 6 report, Pregont recommended demolition, citing the building's condition and the repeated failure of rehabilitation efforts.
The city also has documented a history of property maintenance and safety concerns at the site.
According to the agenda materials, the proposed demolition would not involve an expense to the City of Atchison.
City staff is recommending approval of the resolution, acknowledging that the proposal involves competing priorities between economic development and historic preservation.
If commissioners approve the resolution, the city manager would be required to notify the State Historic Preservation Office of the determination within five days and provide supporting documentation.
The meeting is scheduled for this afternoon, Monday, November 16, at Atchison City Hall.








