(KAIR)--The proposed demolition of a historic former Atchison elementary school to make way for Benedictine College's planned School of Osteopathic Medicine campus received unanimous support Monday from the Atchison City Commission.
Commissioners voted 5-0 during their November 16 meeting to approve Resolution 3461, determining that no feasible and prudent alternative exists to demolishing the former John A. Martin Grade School, commonly known as Martin East, at 507 Unity Street.
The building, which has been vacant since 1997, is listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
During Monday's meeting, City Manager Mark Westhoff presented an extensive history of the property, outlining nearly three decades of unsuccessful efforts to rehabilitate or redevelop the former school.
Those efforts included proposals for affordable housing, market-rate apartments, student housing and, most recently, incorporating the existing structure into Benedictine College's proposed medical school campus.
Westhoff said the building's deteriorating condition, structural problems, safety concerns and renovation costs have repeatedly prevented redevelopment efforts from moving forward.
He noted that structural problems were documented as early as 1990, when the building was still being used as a school.
Years of water infiltration, roof deterioration, vandalism and other maintenance problems have further damaged the structure.
Westhoff described the building as little more than a shell, with much of its roof gone and significant damage throughout.
Benedictine College reacquired the property in 2025 as part of its plans for a School of Osteopathic Medicine. The college initially explored preserving the historic building and incorporating it into the planned campus.
However, a representative of Benedictine College told commissioners that extensive evaluations by architects, engineers and construction specialists found that preserving the structure would be considerably more expensive than replacing it.
According to the college's evaluation, retaining and rehabilitating Martin East would cost at least $3 million more than constructing a new building, even after accounting for available historic tax credits.
The representative also said incorporating the existing structure would result in approximately 6,000 square feet less usable space compared with a new facility.
The college examined 10 possible designs before determining that demolition and new construction would better accommodate the medical school's needs.
The building's listing on the National Register of Historic Places requires additional review before demolition can proceed.
The Kansas State Historic Preservation Office previously determined that demolition would harm the historic structure, triggering a requirement for the city to examine whether feasible and prudent alternatives exist.
City officials reviewed previous redevelopment proposals, structural assessments, financial considerations and the building's history of code enforcement issues before recommending approval of the resolution.
During Monday's discussion, commissioners expressed support for moving forward, citing the building's long history of deterioration and the potential benefits of the proposed medical school campus.
Mayor La Rochelle Young and other commissioners said the project represented an opportunity for growth while addressing a property that has remained vacant for nearly three decades.
The commission's unanimous vote establishes the city's determination that no feasible and prudent alternative to demolition exists.
However, the vote does not mean demolition can begin immediately.
Westhoff said the resolution and supporting documentation must be forwarded to the Kansas State Historic Preservation Office, followed by a required waiting period before the city can issue a demolition permit.
According to the City, the proposed demolition would not involve an expense to the City of Atchison.








